June 11, 2023

Why 'Copy & Paste' is Not a Marketing Strategy: The Risks of Copycat Advertising

In the bustling landscape of the UK's private dental sector, practice owners face many marketing challenges. 

The hurdles are numerous, from attracting new patients for their dental treatment, managing an online presence, and standing tall amidst fierce competition, to optimising word-of-mouth referrals and grappling with the intricacies of digital marketing. 

Reading time: 15 minutes

Adding to these, the concerns of cost, time, effectiveness, prior unpleasant experiences, and the belief that their patient base doesn't utilise online platforms make the task even more formidable. 

Some practices may be tempted to take shortcuts in this quest for growth. 

One such shortcut—duplicating competitors' adverts on platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Google Ads—may seem attractive but is riddled with potential pitfalls. 

This article delves into the top five issues with this seemingly lucrative strategy: a lack of authenticity, addressing different target audiences, infringement of intellectual property rights, diminishing returns and ad fatigue, and violations of Google and Facebook policies. 

As you navigate the intricate world of digital marketing, this guide aims to shed light on these issues, providing you with the knowledge to make informed decisions and create an effective, authentic, and sustainable marketing strategy for your dental practice.

A Costly Misunderstanding

It's quite a common misconception that duplicating a competitor's advertising strategy will lead to similar success. 

Here are the top five problems that private dental practices could encounter if they attempt to directly replicate their competitors' adverts on platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Google Ads:

  1. Lack of Authenticity: Your practice has a unique story, team, and services. Copying a competitor's advert can dilute your unique selling proposition and make your practice appear insincere. Patients are looking for authentic practices that they can trust, and a lack of authenticity can deter potential patients from choosing your practice.
  2. Different Target Audiences: It's important to remember that each dental practice may have a different target audience with unique needs and preferences. The messaging and approach that works for one practice may not resonate with your specific audience. This could lead to poor campaign performance and wasted advertising budget.
  3. Infringement of Intellectual Property Rights: Directly duplicating your competitors' adverts could potentially lead to legal issues. Creatives such as images, videos, and even certain phrases can be protected by intellectual property laws. Copying these elements can lead to your adverts being taken down, or worse, legal action.
  4. Diminishing Returns and Ad Fatigue: When audiences see the same or very similar advertisements multiple times, they can experience 'ad fatigue', leading to lower engagement and effectiveness over time. Duplicating your competitors' adverts could exacerbate this problem, making your marketing efforts less impactful.
  5. Google and Facebook Policy Violations: Both Google and Facebook have policies against deceptive practices. If your ads are too similar to your competitors', they might be flagged for policy violation. This could lead to penalties, including having your ads taken down or even a ban on advertising on these platforms.

Remember, while it's essential to keep an eye on your competitors and learn from their strategies, it's equally important to maintain your own unique brand awareness and authentic approach. 

Tailoring your marketing efforts to your practice's unique selling points and your target audience's specific needs will yield better results in the long run.

Let's dive in.

back to the top

1. The Price of Imitation: Undermining Authenticity

In the highly competitive world of private dental practices, it's only natural for business owners to monitor their competition. The emergence of digital platforms such as Facebook, Instagram, and the Google search engine has made monitoring competitors' marketing strategies, websites and techniques easier than ever. 

However, it's important to distinguish between learning from competitors and directly duplicating their efforts. The latter can lead to many problems, perhaps the most critical one is the erosion of authenticity.

Imagine this: you're a private dental practice owner in the UK, and you've just noticed that a rival practice's social media campaign is gaining traction. It's tempting to copy their adverts verbatim, but is this a good idea? The answer is no, and here's why: it compromises the authenticity of your practice.

So, what is authenticity, and why is it so important? 

Authenticity is about being genuine, honest, and transparent. It's about showcasing your practice's unique identity, values, and vision through your websites and related articles.

Authenticity forms the backbone of the patient-practice relationship for dental practices, creating trust and loyalty that can't be bought with a marketing budget alone. 

Patients who perceive your practice as authentic are likelier to choose your services, remain loyal, and even recommend you to their network. 

Now, let's delve into how duplicating competitors' adverts can undermine your practice's authenticity.

Your Unique Selling Proposition (USP) Gets Lost

Every dental practice has a USP which sets it apart. It could be your innovative services, approach to patient care, experienced team, or even your practice's history and values. This USP draws patients to your practice rather than the ones down the road. When you copy a competitor's adverts, your USP gets lost in the noise. You blend into the crowd when you should be standing out. 

Patients Can Sense Inauthenticity

Patients today are savvy and discerning. They can sense when a business isn't genuine, and this can lead to scepticism and mistrust. Inauthentic adverts can give potential patients the impression that your practice is more interested in making a quick profit than genuinely caring for their oral health. This could deter them from choosing your practice and even tarnish your reputation in the long run.

An Authentic Practice Tells Its Own Story

Each private dental practice's unique story is shaped by its history, team, values, and community. This story is what makes your practice relatable and memorable. It's what helps you connect with patients on a deeper level. 

When you duplicate your competitors' adverts, you're telling their story, not yours. 

Your practice's unique narrative gets lost, and the opportunity to build meaningful connections with patients is also lost.

Inauthenticity Can Hamper Patient Loyalty and Referrals

Authenticity isn't just about attracting new patients; it's also about retaining existing ones and encouraging referrals. Patients who perceive your practice as authentic are likelier to remain loyal and recommend your services to their network. When your adverts lack authenticity, they can hamper patient loyalty and word-of-mouth referrals, two crucial elements for the growth of private dental practices.

While it's essential to monitor your competitors and learn from their successes, it's equally important to maintain your practice's authenticity in your marketing efforts. Duplicating competitors' adverts can undermine authenticity, tarnishing your reputation and weakening patient relationships. 

Instead of copying, craft a marketing strategy that reflects your practice's unique identity and values. This authenticity will resonate with patients, setting your practice apart in the crowded dental industry. 

Your marketing strategy should attract patients and make them feel valued, heard, and cared for. After all, in private dental practices, authenticity is more than a buzzword; it's a promise to your patients that they can trust you with their oral health. It assures that your practice is not just another dental clinic but a community that genuinely cares for its patients. 

So, the next time you find yourself tempted to duplicate a competitor's advert, take a step back and remember the importance of authenticity. 

Instead, draw inspiration from successful campaigns, but always infuse your unique touch into every advert like you would a blog post. In doing so, you will honour your practice's authenticity and cultivate trust and loyalty among your patients, ultimately paving the way for sustainable growth and success in the competitive landscape of private dental practices. 

Remember, your practice is one-of-a-kind, and your marketing should reflect that. Embrace authenticity, and let your unique light shine in your marketing efforts. After all, there's no better way to stand out in the crowd.

back to the top

2. The Perils of Ignoring Audience Differences

In the competitive landscape of the private dental practice industry, it's not uncommon to see businesses scanning the horizon to see what their rivals are doing. While keeping abreast of the competition can provide valuable insights, directly mimicking their advertising strategies can be a major pitfall, especially regarding the nuances of target audiences.

Every marketing campaign begins with understanding your audience's needs, preferences, and behaviours. The adage' One size fits all doesn't apply in marketing. Thus, duplicating your competitor's Facebook, Instagram, or Google Ads without a second thought about audience differences can have detrimental effects. 

So, why does this matter? Let's delve into the implications of ignoring target audience differences.

Understanding Your Unique Patient Base

Every private dental practice has a unique patient base. Your practice may cater to families, young professionals, retirees, or a blend of all three. Each group will have different dental needs and concerns, and these should be at the heart of your marketing strategy. 

When you duplicate a competitor's advert, you communicate with their audience, not yours. 

This could lead to ineffective campaigns that don't resonate with your patients, reducing the return on your marketing investment.

Different Audiences, Different Pain Points

The pain points – the problems or concerns your patients seek to address – can vary significantly between different audiences. For example, a young professional may be interested in cosmetic dentistry, while a retiree might be more concerned about dental implants or dentures. 

By copying a competitor's adverts, you could focus on pain points irrelevant to your audience. As a result, your marketing messages may fall flat, failing to engage potential patients and convince them of the value of your services. Or even worse, attracting the wrong patient leading to a bad experience and poor online reviews.

The Importance of Personalised Messaging

Personalised messaging plays a crucial role in successful marketing campaigns. It allows you to speak directly to your audience, addressing their needs and concerns. When your marketing messages are tailored to your audience, they are more likely to capture attention, build trust, and motivate action. 

Duplicating a competitor's adverts undermines the opportunity for personalised messaging. It's like trying to squeeze into someone else's bespoke suit – it won't fit either. The result? A disconnect between your practice and your patients and a missed opportunity to build strong patient relationships.

Geographical Differences Matter

Private dental practices typically serve a local community. Therefore, geographical factors can significantly influence your target audience and their needs. For example, a practice in a bustling city centre might cater to busy professionals, while one in a suburban area might serve more families. 

If your competitor's practice is located in a different area or serves a diverse community, their successful marketing strategy may translate poorly to your audience. Ignoring these geographical differences can result in marketing messages that fail to reach the mark.

Undermining Brand Consistency

Your brand is more than just your logo or colour scheme. It's the promises you make to your patients, the experience you deliver, and the unique personality of your practice. Consistent branding helps patients recognise and remember your practice. 

You risk undermining your brand consistency when you mimic a competitor's adverts. This can confuse patients and dilute your brand image. 

In summary, while monitoring your competitors can provide valuable insights, it's crucial to remember that your practice serves a unique audience. Duplicating a competitor's adverts without considering target audience differences can lead to ineffective campaigns and wasted resources. Instead, focus on understanding your audience, addressing their unique needs and pain points, and delivering personalised marketing messages. 

This audience-first approach will improve your marketing effectiveness and enhance your practice's brand and reputation. By aligning your marketing strategies with your unique audience and values, you'll be well on attracting and retaining patients who value and appreciate the special services your private dental practice provides.

back to the top

3. Copycat Marketing and Intellectual Property

In today's digital age, information is readily available at our fingertips. This has brought numerous benefits to businesses, including the ability to monitor and learn from competitors. However, in the marketing world, there's a fine line between drawing inspiration and falling into the trap of outright duplication. This is especially pertinent in intellectual property rights, a crucial yet often overlooked aspect of digital marketing for private dental practices.

Intellectual property (IP) rights are legal protections provided to original works' creators, including anything from written content and images to logos and designs. If you duplicate your competitors' adverts on platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Google Ads, you may infringe upon their IP rights. Let's delve deeper into why this is a problem.

Legal Ramifications

Infringing on another business's IP rights can lead to significant legal consequences. Companies have the right to protect their original content, and if they suspect their rights have been violated, they can take legal action. This can result in costly lawsuits, which drain resources and damage your practice's reputation. Avoiding IP infringement is not just about following the law; it's about respecting the time, effort, and creativity that go into producing original marketing content.

Damaging Your Reputation

Trust is a crucial element in the patient-practitioner relationship. Your patients need to trust you with their oral health, and this trust extends to your business practices. If you're found guilty of IP infringement, it can significantly damage your reputation. Patients may start to question your ethics and professionalism, which can lead to losing current patients and difficulty attracting new ones. This can be a critical blow in the dental industry, where word-of-mouth referrals are gold.

Stifling Creativity and Innovation

One of the most significant pitfalls of duplicating competitors' adverts is stifling creativity and innovation. Your marketing campaigns should be a reflection of your unique practice – your values, your mission, and the unique services you offer. By copying others, you're not giving yourself the opportunity to think creatively and innovate. In the long run, this can limit your growth and prevent you from standing out in the highly competitive dental industry.

Loss of Brand Identity

Your brand identity sets you apart from other dental practices. It's what makes your practice unique and what patients remember you by. By copying your competitors, you risk losing this identity. Your adverts may start to look like a mishmash of other practices, and patients may struggle to recognise your unique brand. Over time, this can dilute your brand identity and weaken your connection with your patient base.

Investing in the Wrong Strategy

If you're copying your competitors' adverts because they seem to be successful, you could be investing in a strategy that's not suitable for your practice. What works for one dental practice might not work for another. Many factors contribute to the success of a marketing campaign, including the target audience, the brand identity, and the specific services offered. Blindly investing in a copied strategy may result in wasted resources and poor return on investment.

While it's wise to keep an eye on your competitors, staying on the right side of IP laws and maintaining your unique voice in your marketing efforts is essential.

Instead of duplicating adverts, draw inspiration from them and infuse your unique perspective and values into your campaigns.

Not only will this help you avoid legal trouble and protect your reputation, but it will also encourage innovation and ensure your marketing strategy is tailored to your unique practice and audience. 

Remember, originality and authenticity go a long way in marketing and dental care. By creating marketing content that aligns with your practice's unique identity and values, you'll be able to forge a stronger connection with your patients and attract those who align with your approach to dental care. And isn't that the goal of marketing, after all? To not just attract any patients but the right ones for your practice.

back to the top

4. Diminishing Returns and Ad Fatigue

In the realm of digital marketing for private dental practices, there is a plethora of choices to make, strategies to consider, and pitfalls to avoid. One such pitfall is the temptation to duplicate your competitors' advertisements on platforms such as Facebook, Instagram, and Google Ads. While it might seem like a simple shortcut to success, this approach often leads to diminishing returns and ad fatigue, effectively hampering your marketing efforts. 

Understanding Diminishing Returns

In economic theory, diminishing returns refer to a point at which the benefits gained are less than the amount of effort or money invested. In the context of advertisement duplication, copying your competitors' ads, even if they initially seem successful, may not yield the same results for your practice. Here's why.

Firstly, marketing strategies are not a one-size-fits-all solution. What works well for one dental practice may not work for another due to various factors, such as differences in the target audience, brand identity, and the unique services offered. Copying a competitor's ad tailored to their specific practice and expecting it to work similarly for yours could result in wasted resources and a poor return on investment.

Secondly, the success of an ad often depends on its novelty and ability to capture the audience's attention. By copying an existing ad, you lose the element of surprise, and your ad is less likely to stand out. This can lead to lower engagement and conversion rates, resulting in diminishing returns on your ad spend.

Ad Fatigue: A Direct Consequence

Ad fatigue occurs when your target audience sees your ads so often that they become tired of them. The result? They stop paying attention; worse, they may become annoyed and develop a negative perception of your practice. This can be a direct consequence of ad duplication.

When you duplicate your competitors' ads, particularly in a small industry like private dental practices, your target audience will likely see similar messages across different platforms. This overexposure can quickly lead to ad fatigue, causing your engagement and click-through rates to plummet. 

Striking a Balance

Balancing novelty and familiarity is vital to preventing ad fatigue. Your audience needs to see something new and exciting to catch their attention, but they also need consistency in your branding to build trust and recognition. Creating original ads that reflect your unique brand identity and values makes you more likely to achieve this balance.

Authenticity as a Solution

The solution to diminishing returns and ad fatigue lies in authenticity. Authenticity helps you stand out from your competitors and allows you to connect with your audience on a deeper level. By understanding your patients' needs, preferences, and pain points, you can create targeted ads that resonate with them and encourage them to take action. 

Furthermore, authentic marketing allows you to build a strong brand identity, which is crucial in fostering patient loyalty. Patients are more likely to stick with a dental practice that they feel understands and values them. Creating original and authentic ads can portray your practice as a trusted and reliable dental care provider, encouraging patients to return.

While duplicating your competitors' ads might seem like a quick fix, it's a strategy that's likely to backfire in the long run. 

Instead, invest your resources in understanding your audience and creating authentic, original ads that reflect your practice's unique brand identity and values. This approach prevents ad fatigue and diminishing returns and contributes to a more effective and sustainable marketing strategy for your private dental practice. Remember, in the realm of marketing, originality and authenticity are your keys to success.

back to the top

5. The Legal Pitfalls of Ad Duplication

Getting your private dental practice noticed amongst competitors in the fast-paced digital world can be challenging. It might be tempting to take a shortcut by duplicating your competitors' successful ads on platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Google Ads. However, besides ethical and strategic reasons, a legal aspect makes this approach quite risky: violating Google and Facebook policies. 

A Glimpse into Google and Facebook's Advertising Policies

Both Google and Facebook have established strict advertising policies to maintain a secure, efficient, and enjoyable environment for users and advertisers. These policies cover many topics, including prohibited practices and restricted content. 

One key policy relevant to our discussion is prohibiting intellectual property infringement. Both platforms explicitly state that ads must not violate the intellectual property rights of others, including copyright and trademark laws. 

Infringement of Intellectual Property Rights

When you duplicate a competitor's ad, you risk infringing their intellectual property rights. If an ad design, copy, or idea is original and distinctive, it may be protected by copyright or trademark laws. Even if it's not registered, the creator often has certain rights. Using these without permission could land you in legal trouble.

If the original creator of the ad reports the infringement to Google or Facebook, they are likely to take action. These platforms are obliged to respond to reports of alleged copyright or trademark infringement; their typical response is to remove the infringing ads.

The Consequences of Policy Violations

Violating Google or Facebook's advertising policies can have serious consequences for your dental practice. First and foremost, your ads could be disapproved, or your ad account could be suspended. This means your current and future ads won't run, severely hampering your marketing efforts. 

Furthermore, repeated violations could lead to your account being permanently disabled, meaning you'll lose the ability to advertise on these platforms. This can be a significant setback, considering the vast reach and targeting capabilities of Google and Facebook ads.

In addition to these platform-specific consequences, intellectual property infringement could result in legal action by the original ad creator. This could lead to financial penalties and damage to your practice's reputation.

Navigating Google and Facebook Policies

To avoid these consequences, it's crucial to familiarise yourself with Google and Facebook's advertising policies and ensure that all your ads comply. This includes refraining from ad duplication and adhering to all other guidelines regarding ad content and practices.

When creating your ads, make sure to use original copy and design elements. If you wish to use someone else's content, ensure that you have obtained the necessary permissions. 

The Power of Authentic Advertising

While it might seem easier to duplicate what's already working for others, creating authentic and original ads can be far more rewarding. Authentic advertising allows you to showcase your dental practice's unique offerings and values, helping you connect with your audience on a deeper level.

By creating ads that reflect your practice's identity and cater to your patients' needs, you can build a strong brand image, foster patient loyalty, and ultimately drive growth for your practice. 

So, while the world of digital advertising offers vast opportunities for your private dental practice, it's crucial to navigate it with caution and respect for the rules. Duplication of your competitors' ads might seem like a shortcut to success, but it can lead to Google and Facebook policy violations with severe consequences. 

Instead, invest your efforts in understanding your patients and creating original, authentic ads that resonate with them. Not only will this approach keep you on the right side of the law, but it will also contribute to a more effective and sustainable marketing strategy.

back to the top

Rising Above the Quagmire

Navigating the complex labyrinth of digital marketing can be daunting for private dental practices in the UK. The desire to attract more patients, establish a solid online presence, and stay ahead of the competition often leads to considering quick fixes, such as duplicating competitors' adverts. However, as we have examined in depth, this approach is fraught with significant pitfalls.

The issues of authenticity, target audience mismatch, intellectual property rights, diminishing returns, and policy violations pose substantial challenges and risks. When a practice chooses to duplicate an advert, it compromises its unique voice and fails to connect genuinely with its patient base. Misaligned target audiences may lead to wasted marketing efforts, while intellectual property infringement can have severe legal repercussions.

Moreover, ad fatigue and diminishing returns can significantly degrade the effectiveness of your marketing campaign. And, crucially, duplicating adverts may violate Google and Facebook's advertising policies, potentially causing your ads to be disapproved or your accounts to be suspended.

In conclusion, while digital marketing challenges for private dental practices are substantial, shortcuts like advert duplication are not the answer. 

Instead, practices should strive to understand their unique patient base, create authentic and original content, and stay informed about and compliant with digital advertising policies. This approach avoids the pitfalls of advert duplication and contributes to a robust and effective marketing strategy that can genuinely drive growth for your practice.

back to the top

So, what's next?

In case you're wondering what to do next, or perhaps how, we could help you with your own business, we've got just the thing.

Using data from a three year Harvard Business School study, and best marketing practice we created the Missed Revenue Quiz. In only five questions, using your existing enquiry data, we can show you how much money you could be leaving on the table.

Take the Quiz here: https://takethequiz.dental/

back to the top

That's why our's isn't boring. Stay up to date by subscribing here.
Subscribe now
menucross-circle linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram